Courtroom Watch: The Grain-Free Scare on Trial
Courtroom Watch: The Grain-Free Scare on Trial
In July a US federal appeals court revived part of a US$2.6 billion false-advertising lawsuit against Hill's over the grain-free heart-disease scare. Nothing has been proven yet. The case goes on.
The Case
The lawsuit is against Hill's Pet Nutrition, the company behind Hill's Science Diet. In July the US appeals court ruled that the lawsuit plausibly alleges some of Hill's website statements and vet-education materials were "literally false." That is a ruling on what the lawsuit may argue, not a finding that Hill's advertised falsely. Some claims stay dismissed, and the case could still be thrown out. Nothing has been proven yet. The case goes on.
The Part That Matters More Than the Lawsuit
The US FDA looked into grain-free food and DCM. In December 2022 it said its data didn't establish that grain-free food causes heart disease. Researchers are still studying diet and DCM, but that update never got nearly the airtime the original scare did.
The Question Worth Asking
The scare was about taurine and the heart. So the question worth asking about any food is where its taurine comes from. Ours comes from the food: beef heart, lung and wild salmon. No synthetic taurine added.
We're not vets, and this isn't medical advice. But when a story like this shapes what people feed their dogs, it's worth knowing where it actually came from.
Read next: Heart, Taurine, and Why We Never Changed a Thing: where taurine comes from, and why our recipe never had to change.





